NAB told: Carry on killing asterisks
NAB bank is allowed to depict violence to asterisks, the Advertising Standards Board has ruled.
In a campaign prior to NAB launching its The Break Up project, it created a series of ads featuring comedy asterisks being “killed”.
But one complaint about an animated version of the ad stated: “They make the asterisks into children – playing and giggling and then they kill them – this appears quite a violent action and distresses me as they seem lifelike.”
In all seriousness who are the people that complain about this stuff to the ASB?
Like “I wonder”, I wonder… and increasingly the answer has to be “other banks and their agencies”.
To misappropriate a famous quote:
“The advertising game is a cruel and shallow money trench, a long plastic hallway where thieves and pimps run free, and good men die like dogs. There’s also a negative side.”
It is ridiculous that one complaint to the ASB leads to action. Surely one complaint in a national campaign with high R&F would indicate to the board there is no problem and the person is a crank. The complainants should also be forced to provide their identities, that they can make crackpot complaints anonymously is a joke.
The fact that the ASB entertains these ridiculous complaints in the first place warrants a complaint. Consider it done.
@Tom, I think Hunter S was referring to the TV business…
Perhaps as in our law courts, the people bringing vexatious and time wasting complaints such as this, should be forced to pay the costs of the ASB and NAB when the complaints are thrown out.
Just a thought.
People do have the right to complain and we need to preserve that right.
But should a single individual’s voice be given such disproprtionate weight? Maybe the ASB should not need to investigate until there is (say) 25 or 50 written complaints.
I would agree with highlighting this and banning it. If you study things from a psychology perspective you see how important it is.
Equally the completely ridiculous Sneezesafe campaign labelled CATCH IT, BIN IT, KILL IT instructs children to commit murder multiple times during the Ad. Ludicrous, should be pulled instantly and never should have gone to air on television.
Again it seems trivial but if you understand the effect it can have, you would shudder at the thought of putting such imagery out there. What is wrong with CATCH IT, BIN IT, FINISH IT ?? 🙂
If anyone wants to note a ridiculous one-complaint ad-pull it’s the recent Qantas example whereupon the picture of two fans idolising their favourite rugby player was removed due to one complaint, despite the rugby player insisting it stay up. The removal of that Ad takes coloured people further away from complete inclusion, maintaining barriers to the actual acceptance and integration of ethnically diverse people together and creating us all as a singular in-group in Australia.
You can look at things layman whinger style devoid of in-depth thought or informed grounding, or you can see things from a behavioural perspective based on fact – sadly most opt for the latter due to the first being non-existent.
Oops that should be “opt for the former due to the latter being non-existent” … 🙂